by Tracy C. Brown
I must be honest with you. After reading the article below, which was just published in The New York Times (NYT), I feel confused, angry, and personally shaken to my very core. However, I am not going to write a long, personal opinion article here. They (whoever “they” are) say it is always best to gather facts and a thorough understanding of a topic before launching into a bitter, angry diatribe. Therefore, I shall abide by that longstanding wisdom for now. If you, as a taxpayer and a member of the American public, have any interest at all in Native American archaeology, museum collections, and artifacts, you absolutely must read the NYT article at the following safe link:
https://www.yahoo.com/news/leading-museums-remove-native-displays-183325697.html
Here are a few key questions:
(1) I am a professional archaeologist, a very well-read human being, and an intensive daily news hound. How and why am I (and many of you) hearing about these new federal regulations just now—–after the fact? As noted in the NYT article, these regulations went into effect only two weeks ago.
(2) Why was the American public never widely and intensively informed about these new regulations in the various news media? From inception to final promulgation, it takes a long time to conceptualize and finalize new federal regulations. Surely, I and everyone else should have been widely aware of these new federal regulations long before now.
(3) Oh, sure. I have known about NAGPRA repatriation ever since 1990. Everyone in American archaeology has known about that for a very long time. Why did the American archaeology community not go out of its way to widely inform the American public (and the Tennessee public) about these new regulations that went into effect only two weeks ago?
(4) Are these new regulations the product of a quiet, behind-the-scenes stealth operation between the Biden administration and Native American groups, with American archaeologists and museum directors sitting on the sidelines—–nervously biting their fingernails—–too scared and politically steamrolled to speak up for their own interests and to inform the American public?
(5) How far are we from that future moment when Native American groups finally demand that all American archaeology involving prehistoric Native Americans and Historic period Native Americans must cease and be shut down entirely—–forever? Will anyone speak up for American archaeology when that day finally and inevitably comes?
——This short article is dedicated to my recently deceased archaeological colleague and friend Donald B. Ball of Louisville, Kentucky. If he were still alive and had written anything at all about this subject, it would have been 1,000,000 degrees Fahrenheit and thoroughly blistering. RIP old friend.